You have a number of material options when it comes to your home’s roof, and deciding which is ideal for your needs is important if you’re looking into roof replacement or new roof installation. Two common options here are asphalt and shake roof materials – what should you be considering when it comes to asphalt roofs vs shake roofs for your needs?
At The Roof Doctor, we’re proud to offer the best roof replacement and new roof installation services available around Salt Lake City, Sandy, West Jordan, West Valley City, and nearby parts of Utah. We offer a variety of high-quality roofing materials, including both asphalt and shake roof options. Here are some of the basics on asphalt and shake roofs (also called wood shake roofs), some areas of comparison between them, and some tips on how to choose the ideal option for your home.
Defining Both Types
For those just learning about roofing materials, here are basic definitions of asphalt roofs vs shake roofs:
- Asphalt shingles: Perhaps the single most common roofing material out there is the asphalt shingle, which is made from a type of fiberglass matting covered in asphalt. These are attached to the roof in overlapping rows and often come in many different colors and textures.
- Shake roofs: Wood shake roofing materials, on the other hand, are much more niche – though they do have a dedicated following that appreciates their natural look. They are made from split logs rather than being manufactured like asphalt shingles.
Let’s go through a few key areas and compare these two products.
Cost
One area that can vary widely when discussing asphalt roofs vs shake roofs is the overall cost. Asphalt shingles are typically more affordable for up-front costs, with installation usually being a bit quicker and easier than wood shakes.
Long-term costs are where the picture gets a bit murkier, as so much of it surrounds proper maintenance and care. Wood shakes need to be treated and cared for regularly in order to reach their maximum potential lifespan. If these steps are not taken, the cost of repairs and replacements could add up quickly.
On the other hand, asphalt shingles may require less maintenance but can have a shorter overall lifespan compared to wooden shakes. This means that while they may be more affordable initially, homeowners may end up replacing them more frequently in the long run.
Durability
Again, much of the question of whether asphalt shingles or wood shake roofs are preferable from a durability perspective comes back to the quality of care and maintenance they receive. If properly maintained, both types of roofs can last for many years.
Wood shakes are typically more resistant to extreme weather conditions such as strong winds and heavy rainfall compared to asphalt shingles. This is because wood has a natural flexibility that allows it to withstand these forces without breaking or cracking. However, if left untreated or not properly maintained, wood shake roofs can be susceptible to rot, mold, and insect infestations.
On the other hand, while asphalt shingles may not have the same natural durability as wooden shakes, newer technology and materials have made them much stronger in recent years. High-quality asphalt shingle roofs can now last up to 30 years with proper care and maintenance.
Appearance
One area that mostly comes down to personal preference when choosing between asphalt roofs vs shake roofs is appearance. Both types of roofs have their own unique aesthetic qualities, and it’s important to consider which one best suits the overall look of your home or building.
Wood shake roofs are often praised for their natural and rustic appearance that can add character and charm to a home. However, over time, the color may fade and the wood may start to age and weather, giving it a worn-out look. On the other hand, asphalt shingles come in a variety of colors and styles, making them customizable to fit any architectural style or personal taste. They also maintain their color and shape for longer periods of time than wood shakes.
Qualities for Utah’s Climate
For Utah’s dry desert climate, both asphalt shingles and wood shake roofs tend to be suitable options. However, asphalt shingles have the advantage of being able to withstand extreme heat and UV exposure without warping or cracking. This makes them a more durable option for homes in Utah that experience hot summers.
On the other hand, wood shakes may be prone to warping or rotting in high temperatures and dry conditions. Additionally, wood is a natural material that can attract pests such as termites, which can cause damage to the roof over time. Luckily, the right protection can avoid both these issues.
As you can see, there are several key areas to compare when considering asphalt roofs vs shake roofs. At The Roof Doctor, we’re here to provide quality roofing materials and services to clients around SLC, Sandy, West Jordan, West Valley City and nearby areas of Utah. Contact us today to get started!
